In Tuesday’s #assnchat we talked about the many HR issues an association must consider in the Web 2.0 age. The moderator of the chat, Kiki L’Italien, gave us five questions to discuss. We covered a lot so I’m breaking it into two blog posts. I’ll publish Part 2 tomorrow morning.

1. How does social media impact HR and how are associations adapting?

Unfortunately a lot of associations are not addressing these emerging issues which is why this subject needs more exposure. Although many national associations have a professional HR department, and hopefully their HR staff is being brought up to speed through their own professional development, most state (or smaller) associations don’t have the luxury of a dedicated HR department or person. HR is usually part of someone’s responsibilities – payroll, finance, operations, CEO – and they may not be aware of these critical issues.

HR has a lot more to deal with now:

  • Understanding new social media proficiencies for hiring and promotion decisions, and how to use social media legally during the hiring process.
  • Creating meaningful and user-friendly social media guidelines. If Roche, a global company in the regulated pharmaceutical industry, can create effective and concise guidelines for its staff, an association can do the same.
  • Developing social media training programs for staff.
  • Dealing with succession issues for social media staff. Is your social media use siloed with one person or department? What if that voice and face of the organization leaves?
  • Knowing the appropriate and market-rate compensation for social media staff. ASAE doesn’t have a salary survey yet for social media and community management jobs; salary consultants don’t know what to benchmark against.

2. How heavy should the weight be for/against a potential employee based on social media sites they are on?

Recruiters advise us to create a social media footprint in order to get noticed, particularly those looking for social media jobs. But there are serious legal risks to using social media during the hiring practice. Leslie White in her recent post, Keep it Legal: Social Media & Hiring, recommends that someone not involved in the hiring decision check out a candidate’s social media presence and only report back the information that is legal for an employer to ask a candidate, or risk facing discrimination suits.

social media associations

flickr photo by krossbow

3. Does an HR director or HR team need to have social media proficiency? Does a departmental head need it?

The overwhelming answer is “yes.” Otherwise, how can they deal with all the issues raised throughout this chat? How can they understand how to develop good social media guidelines and training for all staff? How can they understand the new recruiting reality and required proficiencies? Tammy Tilley talked of developing policies with people who “aren’t into social media” so have no idea what is/isn’t appropriate. Your HR staff needs to be into social media.

Should the goal of associations be to educate all staff to have some basic level of social media knowledge and proficiency, asked Rene Shonerd. Vickie Lester recommends that all staff be coached on how to represent the association in any medium, not just social media. I believe associations are either going to become more social, or die a slow death. It’s time to start accepting that and teach the skills required for our new environment.

But the reality is quite different. Maggie McGary is often asked by fellow staff “how they can know about social media stuff but not have to use it themselves.” Kiki remarked, “that’s like asking how can I find out about the phone without using it?” Maggie has also been asked “if they can use a fake name with members, or a fake photo.” This would be amusing if it wasn’t so pathetic. She adds, “there is still a LOT of fear, sadly.”

Tomorrow I’ll post the rest of the discussion about Questions 4 and 5:

4. What kind of social media training should organizations provide to staff? What does a good program look like?

5. Are there other issues that HR departments in associations need to be aware of as a result of changing times?

You can find the transcript for #assnchat on What the Hashtag (search for 9-21-10). #assnchat takes place on Twitter every Tuesday at 2:00 p.m. Eastern Time. All those in the association community are invited to lurk or participate.

NEW DATE: Kiki will be following up on this topic in a BlogTalkRadio interview with Leslie White, Laurie Ruettimann and Brian Crowley on Monday, October 11 at 11:30 a.m. Eastern.

I’ve been writing a series of posts for SmartBlog Insights called Social Strategies for Associations. It’s inspired by a post that Umair Haque wrote for the Harvard Business Review blog, From Social Media to Social Strategy. Haque believes social strategies will change the essence of organizations and social media tools can be a catalyst for that change. I’ve been talking about that for a while so his post really resonated with me. He talks about seven social strategies that will be the key to success and help organizations provide meaningful and sustainable value to members, customers and communities.

I’m riffing off each one of his social strategies, all cornily beginning with the letter ‘C’. I’ve already examined Character, Control, and Creativity. This week my Culture post will be published. The remaining posts will cover Clarity, Cohesion and Choreography. If you’re a regular reader of my weekly posts over there, some of my points might be familiar, but I don’t assume that anyone is a regular reader so I continue to play with these topics.

Bookmark and Share

Published originally as a two-part series on SmartBlog Insights.

I was recently introduced to John Kotter’s eight-step process for leading change. How could his process be used to introduce social media to an organization? Social media can sometimes be perceived as annoying, threatening or unnecessary. However, it can also be welcomed as a catalyst for further organizational change.

Kotter says many change efforts fail because organizations don’t take the holistic approach required to see change through. Here are his eight steps to ensure successful change:

  1. Create a sense of urgency. Members now have free online access to knowledge resources and new ways to connect with peers and clients. We need to be the first place they go to for these needs, not another online community or resource. This sense of urgency must be accepted and conveyed by leadership and staff. Dispel any doubts with social media usage statistics, member survey results and market research. Are younger prospects joining at the same rate they used to? Are we meeting their needs? Don’t talk about these issues behind closed doors, share concerns with your entire leadership and educate them about these issues. They might not realize that your association is at risk of becoming irrelevant to some demographic sectors.Are there some on your board who believe there’s no need for change? Isn’t there always a need to adapt, improve and innovate? If they don’t think so, are they truly leaders, or languishers?
  2. Gather your guiding team. You need a cross-departmental team that’s willing to invest their time and professional reputation into making social media work. They’re willing to give new ideas a chance – they’re not the usual devil’s advocates. They’re communicators who naturally share and listen to others. They have influence or power; they’ll help others understand what’s going on and encourage them to buy in and participate.
  3. Together, create a compelling vision and strategy. Paint a picture of the ideal association that could emerge as a result of this strategy. Show how the association’s goals will be met, how member needs will be met (and perhaps exceeded), how members will interact with the association and each other, and how the association will be different and better. Outline how that’s going to happen – the steps of your strategy.
  4. Communicate this vision and strategy clearly so everyone else (staff, leaders, members) can understand and buy into it. Explain why this new vision and strategy is necessary, what that future association looks like, why it’s better and what’s in it for them. There will always be naysayers — those who don’t see the need to change and improve. That’s their baggage; they carry it with them everywhere, not only in your association. Don’t let them hold you back. The vision and strategy you share will encourage others to support your plans and maybe even get involved.
  5. Empower others to act on that change vision. Identify the organizational barriers (both real and perceived) that prevent others from buying into new programs like social media. These barriers may originate in existing systems and procedures, or in staff attitudes. Social media is a learning process for everyone. Encourage and support those who propose new ideas and are willing to take risks or even willing to try new things. Do your performance evaluations reward innovation or convention? Brave hearts or weak spines? Don’t reward the “I’m just hanging in until my 401(k) is vested” crowd. Educate those who aren’t wired for change in a non-threatening way so that they see the benefits, both for your members and your organization, and get on board.
  6. Aim for short-term wins. Although social media is a long-term effort, establish a few short-term measurable goals and share those early success stories so everyone knows that the investment of time (and reputation) is worth it. Hopefully this will stifle your doubters. Recognize and reward your team. Boost their morale and motivation, especially if their workload or stress increases in the short-term.
  7. Don’t let up. Keep fine-tuning. Review what’s not working and make changes to improve your efforts. Use the experience and resulting credibility from social media adoption as a lever to make other organizational changes. Take a hard look at existing systems and procedures. How much time does staff spend on this “make work” instead of actually getting things done? Where can your association become more nimble and less bureaucratic? Get fierce with the “that’s the way we’ve always done it” mentality that can undermine any vision. Continual education and communication can help ease discomfort and pave the way for needed changes. Relapse to old ways will be tempting for those who may outwardly celebrate your achievements but who inwardly feel threatened by new relationships and programs they don’t fully understand and long for the safe and predictable.
  8. Nurture a new change culture. Institutionalize the change mentality. Make change management a part of your staff and leadership training to ensure that incoming leaders will not revert to old ways. Change will lead to new behaviors – collaboration, openness, releasing control (gasp!) – that must be encouraged. Know that the risk-taking involved will also lead to some failures. However, failures are a chance to learn and improve. A change in organizational culture will take time and may result in the loss of longtime staff, and even leaders, along the way. It’s up to your leaders to persuade others that change is necessary for the association to succeed and survive. Change is the new normal.

Bookmark and Share

SmartBlog Insights recently published a two-part post I wrote — Upward-Facing Associations (part 1 and part 2) — about what we can learn from innovative companies like Lululemon. I wrote these posts for a readership of association professionals, but all of these ideas are ripe for picking by for-profit companies as well.

Innovative companies can be a source of new perspectives and ideas about organizational culture and customer (or member) experience. Lululemon Athletica makes hip high-quality clothing for yoga and other “sweaty pursuits” for their 100-plus stores. Last year their sales increased by 50%. Some of this can be attributed to the growing popularity of yoga, particularly among those willing to pay $98 for yoga pants, but there’s more to it.  Lululemon has been very intentional in how they brand their stores as community hubs where customers can learn about fitness and healthy living, take free classes, and, yes, buy cool tank tops. What can we learn from them?

http://www.flickr.com/photos/mikeschinkel/286734284/

photo Flickr/MikeSchinkel

Here are some of the ideas I shared with some additional thoughts:

  • Give staff the tools to grow not only professionally but personally too. Besides offering professional development opportunities, also provide career and personal goal-setting training, and other personal development resources. You may end up with an educated, forward-thinking, goal-oriented, centered and appreciative staff.
  • Encourage staff to have balanced and healthy lives. For example, allow for flexible schedules so they have time to include yoga, fitness classes and other sweaty pursuits into their busy schedules. Anyone who works out or practices yoga on a regular basis can attest to its effect on their energy level and outlook on life, a positive effect that influences productivity and attitude.
  • Review employee handbooks and other rules and procedures, and welcome change into your organizational culture. Step away from  Standard Operating Procedure. Society, technology and our lives have changed. Why are we still doing things the same way they’ve always been done?
  • Always strive to be a community hub that provides members with the tools they need — knowledge, relationships and advocacy — to have successful professional lives. The emphasis here is on ‘community’ — social media can be a useful tool to do this.
  • Use education to build trust, demonstrate your position as the preeminent source of knowledge and ideas in your profession or industry and develop relationships that result in recruitment and retention — content marketing. Again, social media is an excellent way to share and spread what you excel at already.
  • Check in regularly with your members about their current and future needs. Research the possible needs your members (and their customers) will have in the future. Eliminate stale committees or programs regularly to free up resources for more valuable programs and allow staff to spend their time and energy on things that really matter to members.
  • Consider partnerships with thought leaders, suppliers, service providers or anyone who can provide professional guidance, content or services to your leadership or members. Get creative about how you can bring more to your members. Sometimes collaborating with a competitor can really be a win-win for both of you. Don’t be scared.
  • Have staff spend time each year experiencing what a day (or week) in the life of your member is really like by going on-site or spending time in their office with them. Be open to having that new knowledge and experience inform your member service and programming.

If you know of other innovative companies that I should check out for future blog post inspiration, please let me know.

Bookmark and Share

A new Social Media Revolution video is out with updated stats. The Socialnomics blog published all the stats from their video along with their sources. If you hold any thoughts about social media being a fad or a waste of time, watch this video and you’ll soon learn otherwise.

When David Gammel asked Have You Killed Your Sacred Zombie Cow Today, I could almost hear the cries of jubilation from colleagues (for-profit and non-profit) all over the nation. As he bluntly put it, your sacred cow = crap. It’s tough to try new things when you have to spend your time doing the same old lame stuff. Get your abattoir ready!

The folks at Hubspot tell us how to monitor our company’s social media presence in just ten minutes a day. Ok, maybe you can quickly scan these platforms and alerts in ten minutes, if you have bionic reading ability. But they leave out a critical part — engagement. You need to allow time to respond to comments or tweets. Listening is critical, but it’s only the first step. This is social media — that means conversation. Otherwise, don’t even bother. However, I’m recommending this because it does at least provide five listening exercises that should be done daily, just please take a bit more time with it.

Another checklist! This time, Dan Schawbel gives us his personal branding checklist for Twitter. Dan’s list is good, except for the inspirational quote suggestion, blech. Make us laugh now and then, that’s fine but a slew of bad one-liners makes me think about the “unfollow” button. Here’s my tip: filter your Tweetdeck columns by “?” and see if you can answer someone’s question. It may not be about your field, but you might be able to give someone a recommendation for a beach hotel or where to buy fresh strawberries.

I have a standing weekly lunch on Tuesdays with my fellow Garner women entrepreneurs so I’m never able to participate in the #socialmedia chat on Twitter at noon (Eastern). But I just discovered the website with its archive of chats. Excuse me while I go read for several hours…..

Bookmark and Share

CAE. Certified Association Executive. Many of my friends outside the association industry ask, “what does that mean exactly?” According to ASAE, it means I have demonstrated “the knowledge essential to the practice of association management.” After reading this post, you may decide that in my case it should be renamed Certified Association Geek.

The CAE journey gave me a deeper knowledge and understanding of association management, particularly in areas I never had the opportunity to delve into before. Reading the texts while reflecting upon my ten years of association experience gave me a much better grasp of the challenges of leading and managing an association. My mind grappled with a wide range of topics from the minutia of reporting requirements for lobbying to the more interesting concepts of shared leadership and strategic thinking.

Every week, a new domain entered my life: strategic management; planning and research; leadership; administration; knowledge management; governance and structure; public policy and governmental and external relations; membership; programs, products and services; and public relations and external communications. With each domain came lots of reading, quizzes and a conference call with my study group. I looked forward to my reading time, taking notes as I went, reflecting on what I was reading, what I had seen and how things are changing. I was amazed at how long I would study on weekends. It was a good experience; I knew my knowledge was deepening.

On test day, there was a strange moment about an hour into it when I said to myself, “this is kind of fun.” It might have been the coffee talking, or more likely, I was on a roll with some easy questions. By the end of the four hours, by brain was mush. I was drained. I remember thinking, if I had to bet money, I would bet I passed, but who knows. It was over, all those months of study, over. It was strange putting those books away. The books I had lived with for so long. Then I realized, I have my weekends back and I had a Sierra Nevada Celebration Ale.

Fast forward six weeks and a few days later to this past Tuesday. While running around town that afternoon I got an email from my CAE study buddy, Sandra Giarde, saying the results were out. Our Twitter buddy Aaron announced that he passed. I checked the mailbox on my way home. Empty. The mail was late, really late. Then I had a conference call and couldn’t check the mail for over an hour. Meanwhile three of us who took the exam were emailing back and forth – messages of dread and silliness. After the call I walked back to the mailbox and there they were — two postal workers distributing the mail among the boxes. “Have you done the other side yet?” My side of the boxes. “No ma’am.” I walked home. My palms were sweaty, my heart was racing.

I waited about 20 minutes and walked back, the mail truck was gone. The mailboxes never looked so ominous. I opened my box. It was full of mail. I quickly flipped through the envelopes and magazine, searching for that one envelope. Oh boy. There it is – a business envelope from ASAE marked “confidential.” Moment of truth. I tore it open with my key. “Dear Ms. Reid:” was all I could read on the first fold. Quickly I turned it over and saw the word “Congratulations!” “YES!” I shouted out, and then thought, oh wait, I better make sure, and quickly scanned and saw enough to know that yes, indeed, I had passed the exam and could proudly put the letters CAE beside my name. I let out another whoop and skipped home with a huge grin on my face. I wonder what the neighbors thought. If anyone had been at the boxes with me, I might have hugged them.

I wasn’t expecting to be so over the top happy, my reaction surprised me. But I knew that if I hadn’t passed, I would have been so disappointed and sad; never mind the blow to my pride and ego. All the work, the sacrificed weekends and the new love for my profession – it all paid off in the end.

The letters CAE, they’re validation of what I know, what I’ve been through. But the best thing about this whole process was the journey — the learning, the thinking. Everyone’s CAE experience is probably a bit different. We come to it with varying levels of management and leadership experience, areas of expertise, and views on association challenges and opportunities. We approach the study process in different ways. But no matter the final results, going through the process is a huge accomplishment and stands on its own. Passing makes it sweeter.

If you find our industry at all fascinating and would like a rewarding learning experience, I strongly encourage you to study for the CAE exam. I call it a “journey” because it’s like one of those memorable trips to somewhere new and different. I knew where I was heading — the exam. I had my maps — the study guide and texts. I met some people along the way — my study group. But the best part was the studying and learning — being in the experience — the journey.

My latest guest post for the SmartBrief Insights blog was just published. Lately I’ve been thinking a lot about providing real member value — “sticky” value, the kind that of value that a member couldn’t find elsewhere. And I’ve been thinking about revenue, how critical it is to have a diverse revenue stream — considering my recent experience, this is no surprise. This post touches on some ideas to ensure both member value and revenue.

As I was studying for the Certified Associate Executive (CAE) exam, I came across some ideas by Bruce Butterfield in Professional Practices in Association Management about defining the future. He says that by studying the customers of our members, we can better anticipate the emerging needs of our members and be in a position to provide true value to them. He lays out the steps of this process:

  • Examine the trends and emerging issues that will change the kind of customers the association’s members will face.
  • Identify new demands that these customers will place on the association’s members.
  • Identify the new skills, services and partners our members will need to meet these new demands.
  • Recommend new functions, products and services that the association will need to help its members meet these new needs.
  • Define a new position and revenue models for the association based on the new mission.

Read the rest of my post at SmartBlog Insights.

Last week the Association Executives of North Carolina held an excellent educational session, Top Legal Trends that Associations Should Care About, presented by Marty Martin, JD. There was a lot to digest and it reminded me, once again, of all the challenges a CEO faces. Marty discussed four emerging legal trends that we need to understand and deal with:

  • It seems that every few weeks we learn of the misdeeds of an organization or individual we once trusted. This morning we learned of the arrests of mayors and rabbis (!) in New Jersey. It’s no wonder that a lack of trust in organizations is becoming more pervasive.
  • We demand accountability from our leaders and organizations. We will no longer put up with boards failing in their duties and tolerating unethical behavior or misguided senses of entitlement, as they did at the United Way, Smithsonian, and Nature Conservancy. Associations are tax-exempt organizations, not only accountable to our members but to the public too.
  • Transparency” is a word we see and hear more often these days, but it’s not a passing trend.
  • We’re much more critical about performance and results. If you can’t deliver, we’re going to start asking questions and taking our votes or money elsewhere. Doing well isn’t good enough; we must demonstrate our results to members and the public.

The IRS 990 Form is the most obvious indicator of these trends. If you haven’t looked at one yet because your job doesn’t require you to, take a peek and see what your CEO and Board will be dealing with. Its completion will require a lot more resources and disclosure than many associations are used to. The compensation section alone will give many Executive Directors heartburn and could create staff morale or member value issues when compensation packages of key staff are disclosed.

There must be a renewed emphasis on board governance and management of the association. The board is responsible for managing the business of the corporation – the association. Or do they think the Executive Director is managing it? The standards of service for a non-profit board are the same as a for-profit board. Do they realize that?

Are we selecting our board leaders for the right reasons? Or do other reasons enter the equation – ego, geography, seniority, politics, or relationships?

Do we educate our boards as to their duties and responsibilities? Do they understand conflict of interest? Anti-trust? Fiduciary responsibilities?

Do you get the impression that your board members don’t have the time to do the work they should to understand their responsibilities and prepare for meetings? If they’re not willing to put in the time and effort to do the work, they shouldn’t be on your board. I don’t know the source of this quote from the presentation but it’s a good one: “Your date book is your creed. What you believe in, you have time for.”

Marty defined organizational culture as a pattern of learning that occurs overtime in response to internal and external challenges. Culture operates on three levels, but all three must be aligned for a healthy organization:

  • Surface – The first impressions upon walking into your association’s office speaks to its culture.
  • Espoused values – Are you walking your talk? The board has the ultimate responsibility for adhering to these values, yet I think the Executive Director can play a critical role by modeling the right behavior and actions.
  • Basic assumptions – Assumptions are often hidden because we’re so used to them. “We’ve always done it that way.” They’re often our sacred cows. Assumptions can be an impediment to change in an organization.

In the short term, culture will prevail, even in the face of a changing external legal environment. That’s why associations may need a cultural shift to be transparent, accountable, well-governed and wisely managed.

« Previous PageNext Page »

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 4,770 other followers